I’ve had the Droid for a few days now. Here are my emerging opinions.
Things I like
- Background processes – push email, IM, and notifications in general provide a superior communication experience.
- Surprisingly long battery life. Despite running all those background applications, the phone’s battery is still at half full after 12 hours.
- The LED on the front bezel blinks when you have something waiting for your attention – no need to turn on the screen.
- It’s fast. Most applications seem to have almost no load time.
- The slide out keyboard lights up in the dark.
- Facebook and Google sync everything in the background. When a new contact appears in Gmail, it’s automatically on the phone.
- The screen is extremely readable. Font rendering is especially good compared to the iPhone.
Things I do not like
- The camera takes horrible pictures and does not focus properly.
- Scrolling the home screen is rough.
- The virtual keyboard does not automatically appear when a text input field is highlighted. You have to tap the field to summon the keyboard.
- There is a limit of 3 home screens.
- Some of the applications that I enjoyed on my iPhone do not yet have an Android equivalent. Amazon Kindle is the one I miss the most.
- They layout algorithm for the home screen truncates application names longer than one line, even when there is obviously plenty of space.
- The interface aesthetic needs a lot of work. For starters, the black background featured in some parts of the interface is mismatched with the gray gradient background found in other parts. There needs to be a universal design tying all the components together. This would also help unify the appearance of third party applications as their developers take cues from the standard UI and widget set.
- The volume rocker and camera button have too much play, which makes them feel cheap.

I suspect point #5 on the ‘things you dont like’ will be a big hurdle in preventing Droid from becoming popular. Apple has too much of the mindshare already
Yes, but I think companies are realizing that Android marketshare is a growing minority that will be difficult to ignore in the near future. Looking among my current iPhone apps, I note that Evernote and Dropbox Android apps are in the pipeline.
“Devices running on Android accounted for 17% of U.S. smartphone traffic, up from 13% in August.”
http://www.ismashphone.com/2009/10/admob-mobile-metrics-report-for-september-android-share-is-growing.html
I’m really surprised you don’t have larger complaints about the UI than consistency of the colors… what grade did I give you? :) Really, is it that improved over Android 1? I need to get ahold of one or can I upgrade my G1 yet?
Keywords here: “for starters”
@James Landay
I don’t think you can upgrade your G1 unless you’re willing to install the unoptimized SDK version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ijAgr7v8Mo
@James Landay
Android 2.0 is now available for the G1 – http://www.mobilecrunch.com/2009/11/14/android-2-0-source-released-already-ported-to-the-g1/